No disputing it, it’s a fact. With my compromise antenna, in marginal situations, it is very likely I’ll hear him better than he hears me (working on the basis he probably has a better antenna than mine). So, if I want to work him, I need to radiate enough of a signal for him (or her) to hear me. No antenna means I radiate no signal.
I hear and read a lot of comments from hams in antenna limited situations similar to my own lamenting the fact that they can’t put up the kind of antennas many other hams are using. To all of them I say “do not despair and just put up something…anything!” It will radiate a signal and you will work people. Granted not as many as those other hams with the big fancy antennas but you will make contacts.
Case in point, my current antenna which is (as previous posts have mentioned) a compromise multi-band wire that seems to work quite well (despite the losses recently identified in the previous blog entry) on 20m, 30m and 40m and that will additionally tune and work on 80m, 17m, 15m and 12m. I suppose 7 band coverage on 12 metres of sloping end fed wire isn’t too bad and with this antenna I have worked some nice DX in the past 18 months (116 countries) including:
Alaska, Anguilla, Argentina, Aruba, Australia, Barbados, Bermuda, Bonaire (Curacao), British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Cuba, Desecheo Island, Dodecanese, Faroe Islands, Grenada, Hawaii, Iceland, Iraq, Jamaica, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Martinique, Mauritius, Montserrat, New Zealand, Nigeria, South Africa, St. Maarten, St. Vincent, Sudan, Suriname, Svalbard, Tajikistan, Tanzania, United Arab Emirates, Uruguay, Venezuela and Western Sahara.
This includes 15 all time new ones taking my DXCC total from 162 to 177. Not bad for a pretty simple compromise antenna!
I hope that this blog entry will illustrate to many of the newer hams out there, who are similarly limited in what antennas they can erect, that simple compromise wire antennas can work. I know that there are better antennas and I know that many will always say that “more…higher is better” but the simple truth is that not everyone can get “more…higher”. In those circumstances always remember that something is better than nothing so put up what you can and work some DX!
Dean Amateur Radio, Life... antenna, DX, DXCC